The Dating Game

Posted by on Feb 24, 2012 in Articles | 0 comments

How old is the earth?  There are many scientific ways for dating the earth.  Some ways show the earth to be only hundreds of years old.  Others show it to be thousands of years old, while still others may show an age of billions of years.  The whole problem of dating the earth is that we are trying to date something of unknown ageAll dating methods are based on guesses that may or may not be true. 

This story shows the problem of dating and assumptions.  Suppose a scientist came home one day to find his son Tommy putting away toys in his bedroom.  Being an observant fellow, the scientist noticed that the “second” hand of the wall clock reached twelve just as Tommy dropped a toy into the toy box.  Tommy then walked to another toy, picked it up, returned and dropped it into the toy box, just as the “second” hand on the clock reached twelve once again.  The scientist watched Tommy picking up toys for ten minutes, and then asked himself.  “Wonder how long Tommy has been doing that?”

To answer the question, the scientist went to the toy box and counted 29 toys.  Having just watched (observed) Tommy picking up toys at a rate of one toy per minute, the scientist concluded that Tommy had been picking up toys for 29 minutes.  Is that how long Tommy had been picking up toys?  Well, maybe…To come to that answer the scientist had to make some guesses about the past that he did not observe (see).  If his guesses are wrong, his answer will also be wrong.

The first thing that the scientist had to assume (guess) about the past is that Tommy had been picking up all the toys at a constant rate.  All he scientifically knew is what Tommy had picked up in the last ten minutes.  Perhaps the closer toys did not take as long to pick up as those farther away.  Perhaps Tommy was getting tired and had actually slowed down from when he began.  Or maybe Tommy was getting better at picking up his toys and was doing it faster than when he began.  By observing the present rate, the scientist does not necessarily know the rate of the past.

The scientist then had to guess if there were any toys in the box to start with.  He was not there to observe if the box was empty when Tommy started, therefore he can only guess.  If his guess is wrong, his answer will also be wrong.

The next guess the scientist has to make was if any toys had been added to, or taken away from the toy box before he saw Tommy was putting toys in.  Perhaps, unknown to the scientist, his wife had put away a few toys from the living room before she made Tommy clean up the toys in his room.  Or, maybe Tommy’s sister had borrowed an armful of toys from the toy box and taken them to her room.  The scientist would have absolutely no way of knowing just by looking in the toy box.  He could ask his wife, daughter, or Tommy about how long it took to pick up the toys but he would not really know if what he was told was correct (how many people accurately measure the time it takes to do something?).

How old is the earth?  We can study and know many things about rocks and minerals.  However, rocks, rock layers, or fossils are not found with tags or labels giving their age.  Every dating method used to date rocks essentially uses the same basic ways as the scientist did with his son.  A lot of guesses have to be made about the past.

No method can scientifically prove or disprove the age of the earth.  Thankfully, we have a reliable record in the Word of God, the Bible.  Using the genealogies found in the Bible, the time of the creation of the earth and universe is about 6,000 years ago.  We must make a decision as to what we will believe – the ideas of man or the Word of God.


By Lanny and Marilyn Johnson

Originally Published in the Spring 2003 Kids Think and Believe Too!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

We Have a New Location! 2140 Broadway, Unit B-103. Our phone number has not changed: 970-523-9943 / 800-377-1923.